[ros-dev] Symbolic Links

David Hinz post.center at gmail.com
Thu Dec 1 16:25:39 CET 2005


I don't have to change anything in explorer, I just have to add this 
feature to IFS.
The only thing I could add to explorer is the ability of creating 
symbolic links.

Greets,

David Hinz

Rick Langschultz schrieb:
> It is a very good idea to implement symbolic links in the registry; 
> however, i do find it very difficult to navigate a registry key with 
> hundreds of subkeys. Instead I would rather the system choose how to 
> index the data. Understandibly CPU load and RAM are key factors in 
> implementing such a service but until system services are implemented i 
> find it difficult to complete my part of the feature. Using the registry 
> now is a great place to start. However without rewriting Explorer to 
> interpret those links it will take some amount of time.
> 
> On Dec 1, 2005, at 7:08 AM, David Hinz wrote:
> 
>> Well, if you add these features or plan to add them in the near 
>> future, the service with the MySQL or whatever db would be better for 
>> this, I just said that I like my idea more than yours, because it is 
>> easier to implement.
>> It is true, that the registry would become larger by this, but how 
>> many symbolic links do you want to use? 10000?
>> I think there wouldn't be much more than 100 of those links (and if 
>> there were many more, it would just show, how important this feature 
>> was...), so how slow would a PC have to be that this feature would 
>> slow it measurably down?
>>
>> To say it again, the idea with the db is good, but it is only better 
>> than mine, if you really want to implement the features you mentioned, 
>> because otherwise it would waste a lot of cpu-time and RAM.
>>
>> @Richard: Windows doesn't slow down because of the registry (the 
>> german pc-magazine c't prooved that some months ago), I think it is 
>> because of full and very fragmented harddisks...
>>
>> Greets,
>>
>> David Hinz
>>
>> Rick Langschultz schrieb:
>>> I was thinking more of a self-optimizing database service that would 
>>> allow indexing of files, submitting and retreiving metadata 
>>> information, extended file permissions and DRM (evil) if needed. Also 
>>> it could be built on something small like MySQL with an InnoDB 
>>> backend or even sleepycats or perhaps MaxDB from Mysql because they 
>>> provide the XML indexing engine which could prove very useful when 
>>> modifying data through notepad. Also the service could be controlled 
>>> like Spotlight in Mac OS X Tiger. This indexing service could index 
>>> different file types also and symbolic links would hold higher 
>>> privilege that indexed files. Using the registry is illogical because 
>>> the system goes through each of those keys on startup and loading...
>>> Also with a new explorer interface the XML engine could interact with 
>>> explorer and the desktop in an attempt to create a better ReactOS 
>>> interface.
>>> On Nov 30, 2005, at 5:57 PM, Richard wrote:
>>>> Use the registry?  For symbolic links?  Extra file info?  Are you 
>>>> kidding me?  You DO know why Windows tends to slow down over time 
>>>> right?  Over the months/years the registry gets more and more 
>>>> cluttered with...junk.  What happens when you delete a file?  What 
>>>> happens if the file gets nuked via a disk error?  What happens if a 
>>>> user doesn't WANT symbolic links taking up precious memory (and  
>>>> just because you can get a GB of RAM for $70, a  200 GB HD for under 
>>>> $100, doesn't mean you should try and use all that space on 
>>>> operating system code.  See Vista for an example*)
>>>>
>>>> A service with an integrated db engine is the best way to go if you 
>>>> want to do that, but please remember that NTFS already has support 
>>>> for symbolic links.
>>>>
>>>> Not to say that your idea isn't a good one...it's just better off as 
>>>> a system service, as suggested earlier.
>> _______________________________________________
>> Ros-dev mailing list
>> Ros-dev at reactos.org
>> http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Ros-dev mailing list
> Ros-dev at reactos.org
> http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev
> 


More information about the Ros-dev mailing list