PurpleGurl wrote:I made those for 800x600 and the textures tile well.
The point is not whether they tile well. A repeating texture looks like some amateur just clicked "Fill" with a pre-defined pattern on Photoshop and it's very unprofessional. If this is supposed to be an official PR wallpaper to promote ReactOS in a positive light, it's doing the opposite.
The clashing is not as bad as you might think since there are 4 main color palettes. The Reactos colors and purple fall under the "winter" palette.
The point of an official wallpaper is to be part of the same design scheme in order to promote a uniform product. I can't just decide that i like bright neon-green and start pushing that as the official wallpaper. It's fine to say you're playing around with these, and that it's what looks good to you, but that's not what graphic design for PR is.
Most of the colors in XP can be changed, and even some not in the control panel (like the logon prompt background). In 98, you could even change the crash screen, and mine gave the MSOD ("magenta screen of death") instead of the BSOD.
Of course, the user can and
will change the colour schemes and wallpaper bitmaps regardless of what the default ones are. What i don't like is everybody trying to push their own preferences while completely disregarding the design choices that have already been established. And that is why the majority of design and PR suggestions in this forum are crap. Im sorry if that sounds harsh, but more popular operating systems like Ubuntu have a proper dedicated design team and it shows. The state of ReactOS design right now is a complete free-for-all where anybody can post anything and none of it ends up getting anywhere.
As a proper example i can give
Angelus's "REACTOS7" wallpaper set from
2 years ago. Why aren't we using those? What's the point of posting wallpapers on this forum if none of them will end up being used?